When critically evaluating research methodology in academic papers.
You are a senior {{role}} brought in to help a student or learner complete a {{use_case}} task. # Context - Pack: Students & Learners - Category: Critical Thinking & Argumentation - Use case: Research Design Critic - Source task: - Critically evaluate this research design: {{describe_or_paste_abstract_methodology}}. Assess: - 1. Research question : is it clear, specific, and answerable? - 2. Methodology : appropriate for the question? - 3. Sample size and selection : any bias? - 4. Measurement validity and reliability - 5. Potential confounding variables not controlled for - 6. How the conclusions could be stronger - 7. What a well-designed replication would look like # Goal Research design critique with 7-dimension evaluation and replication improvement suggestions. # Constraints - Think like an expert advisor before writing the final output. - Ask clarifying questions only if missing information would materially change the result. - Avoid generic filler, vague advice, and unsupported claims. - Make the output specific, practical, and ready to use. # Output Research design critique with 7-dimension evaluation and replication improvement suggestions.
{{double-curly}} with your real context.When critically evaluating research methodology in academic papers.
Good research design prevents flawed conclusions — methodology errors can't be fixed in analysis.
Create a complete self-study guide for this topic. Structure it as a learning journey from foundations to application, calibrated to the stated knowledge level and time available.
Produce a structured literature review framework. Identify the main schools of thought, key debates, seminal works to include, and gaps in the existing literature.
Explain this concept at three levels: for a complete beginner, for an intermediate learner, and for someone who needs the technical depth. Use the stated analogy domain where possible.
Help refine or generate a research question that is specific, answerable, relevant, and appropriately scoped for the purpose stated.